The Ultimate Guide to the 7 Best Cheeses for Margherita Pizza

Forget those limp, stringy mozzarella slices! We're talking about the best cheese for margherita pizza, the kind that melts into a creamy, gooey heaven. Think rich, milky mozzarella with a subtle tang, perfect for capturing the flavors of tomato sauce and basil. A good margherita pizza cheese doesn't just top the pie, it elevates it to a whole new level of deliciousness. So, ditch the grocery store cheese and get ready to taste the difference.

Choosing the right pizza stone can significantly impact the final product. A high-quality stone should evenly distribute heat, allowing for crispy crusts, while being durable enough to withstand frequent use. The stone's material and thickness are crucial factors, as they influence heat retention and overall performance.

1. Whole Foods Market 365 Frozen Pizza Cheese (2-Pack)

Whole Foods Market 365 Frozen Pizza Cheese (2-Pack)

I've been using the 365 by Whole Foods Market frozen pizza cheese for a while now and it's become a staple in my freezer. The quality is excellent, and I really appreciate that it's free from hydrogenated oils and FD&C colors. It melts beautifully and adds a great cheesy flavor to my pizzas. I'm also a fan of the fact that Whole Foods Market has such a wide selection of organic and non-GMO products, all at reasonable prices. This pizza cheese is a great example of their commitment to high-quality ingredients and affordable options.

While some users found the cheese bland, others praised its flavor and size, making it ideal for a quick, delicious pizza.

  • Rate: 4.4 / 33

2. California Pizza Kitchen Four Cheese Thin Crust Frozen Pizza

California Pizza Kitchen Four Cheese Thin Crust Frozen Pizza

This California Pizza Kitchen Four Cheese pizza is a winner! The crispy thin crust is perfectly cooked and the mozzarella cheese is generous and flavorful. I love that it's made with 100% real cheese and no artificial flavors. The olive oil sauce adds a nice touch and complements the cheese perfectly. It's also preservative free, which is a huge plus in my book. While I haven't tried the other flavors, I can see why they're popular. This is definitely a pizza I'll be buying again!

This frozen pizza delivers authentic Italian flavors with a thin, crispy crust and a flavorful tomato sauce, making it a top choice for a quick and delicious Margherita experience.

  • Rate: 4.4 / 1871

3. Happy Belly Four Cheese Shredded Pizza Blend (Mozzarella, Smoked Provolone, Parmesan, Romano)

Happy Belly Four Cheese Shredded Pizza Blend (Mozzarella, Smoked Provolone, Parmesan, Romano)
    Highly rated
  • Taste
  • Value for money
  • Meltability
  • Pizza flavor

This Happy Belly shredded four cheese blend is a winner! It's a great mix of mozzarella, smoked provolone, Parmesan, and Romano, and the flavor is fantastic. I especially loved the smoky flavor of the provolone. The blend melts perfectly, and the cheese is the perfect amount of salty. I've been using it on pizzas and in pasta dishes, and it makes everything taste better. This is a real time-saver, too, since it's already shredded. I highly recommend it!

This versatile cheese melts beautifully, making it ideal for pizza and other dishes. Its affordability and convenience make it a great value.

  • Rate: 4.7 / 7671

4. California Pizza Kitchen Margherita Pizza - Crispy Thin Crust, 100% Real Cheese

California Pizza Kitchen Margherita Pizza - Crispy Thin Crust, 100% Real Cheese
    Highly rated
  • Value for money
  • Quality
    Some controversy about
  • Taste
  • Cheese content

This California Pizza Kitchen Margherita pizza is a real winner. It's got that perfect crispy thin crust and is loaded with 100% real mozzarella cheese. They don't skimp on the toppings either, with generous amounts of virgin olive oil and sweet basil. The best part? It's completely free of artificial flavors and preservatives. Plus, it's available in cauliflower, gluten-free, and chickpea crusts, so you can enjoy it no matter your dietary needs. I've tried it a few times now, and it's always a delicious and satisfying meal.

This pizza boasts a delicious, fresh flavor with a thin, crispy crust and a touch of sweetness. The low sodium content makes it a healthy option for pizza lovers.

  • Rate: 4.5 / 2746

5. Amy's Organic Margherita Pizza

Amy
    Highly rated
  • Taste
  • Freeze quality
  • Quality
    Some controversy about
  • Size
  • Thickness
  • Ease of cooking
  • Value for money

Let me tell you, Amy's Margherita pizza is a real winner. It's made with organic tomatoes and basil, and you can really taste the difference. The crust is crispy and the sauce is flavorful, just like a homemade pizza. I love that Amy's uses organic ingredients and is committed to sustainable practices. This pizza is a quick and easy meal that doesn't compromise on taste or quality. Whether you're looking for a vegetarian option or just a delicious and convenient pizza, I highly recommend giving Amy's Margherita a try.

Amy's Margherita Pizza shines with its authentic Italian flavors and crispy crust, offering a delicious and affordable alternative to pricey restaurant meals.

  • Rate: 4.5 / 4108

6. Aplenty Margherita Pizza, Wood-Fired Crust (Frozen)

Aplenty Margherita Pizza, Wood-Fired Crust (Frozen)
    Highly rated
  • Quality
    Some controversy about
  • Taste

This Aplenty Margherita pizza is a real winner. The wood-fired crust is perfectly crispy and has a nice char, just like a real pizzeria. The sauce is tangy and flavorful, and the cheese is melty and gooey. It's a great option for a quick and easy dinner, and it's definitely better than any frozen pizza I've had before. I especially loved the light sprinkle of sea salt on the crust, which really enhanced the flavor. I'd definitely recommend this to anyone looking for a tasty frozen pizza that doesn't sacrifice quality.

This pizza offers a crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and high-quality ingredients at a great price, making it a top choice for a satisfying Margherita pizza experience.

  • Rate: 4.2 / 133

7. Banza Margherita Chickpea Pizza: Gluten-Free & High Protein

Banza Margherita Chickpea Pizza: Gluten-Free & High Protein
    Highly rated
  • Taste
  • Protein content

Let me tell you, this Banza Margherita pizza is a game changer! It's gluten-free, packed with protein, and actually tastes amazing. The chickpea crust is surprisingly chewy and flavorful, and the toppings are generous and fresh. I was skeptical at first, but this pizza definitely surpassed my expectations. The flavor is spot-on, the texture is satisfying, and it's so convenient to have a healthy and delicious pizza option on hand. You won't be disappointed.

Banza Margherita Frozen Pizza offers a delicious, protein-packed gluten-free option that tastes great and is a healthy alternative to traditional pizza.

  • Rate: 4.6 / 948