Ever wondered what makes a pizza truly legendary? We've uncovered the secrets, scouring countless pizza menus and taste tests to bring you the best-selling pizza toppings. From classic pepperoni and its spicy kick to the cheesy pull of mozzarella, these toppings—the stars of countless delicious pies— guarantee pizza perfection. Whether you're crafting your own masterpiece or ordering takeout, these top sellers will elevate your pizza night to legendary status. Discover the ultimate ingredient combinations for your next pizza adventure.
1. Slap Ya Mama Cajun Seasoning: Original Blend, Kosher & MSG-Free (4 oz)
Slap Ya Mama: versatile, delicious Cajun flavor on anything!
- Highly rated
- Flavor
- Quality
Indulge in the authentic taste of Louisiana with Slap Ya Mama Cajun Seasoning, an original blend crafted in Ville Platte, the self-proclaimed smoked meats capital. Created by Anthony "TW" Walker in 1956, this MSG-free and Kosher certified seasoning boasts a true Cajun pepper flavor without excessive salt. Perfect for everything from popcorn to gourmet dishes, this 4-ounce bottle of Slap Ya Mama delivers a zesty kick. The unique blend, originally mixed in an antique pickle jar, has been a family favorite for generations, earning its name from the joyful reactions it inspires. Experience the legendary flavor that has made Slap Ya Mama a Louisiana staple.
Slap Ya Mama Cajun Seasoning delivers a bold, high-quality flavor that elevates any dish. Users rave about its versatility, sprinkling it on everything from chicken and shrimp to eggs, chili, and even pickled eggs! The simple ingredient list belies a complex and delicious taste, far surpassing other blander Cajun seasonings on the market. Many have been loyal customers for over a decade, praising its ability to add a delightful Cajun kick without overwhelming spice. While some comment on higher pricing online compared to in-store bulk purchases, the exceptional taste and wide range of culinary applications (from soups to air-fried delights) make Slap Ya Mama a kitchen essential. This versatile seasoning is a true taste sensation – a testament to its superior quality and irresistible flavor.
- Brand: SLAP YA MAMA
- Item Form: Powder
- Specialty: no msg, kosher
- Unit Count: 4.0 Ounce
- Rate: 4.6 / 8498
- Authentic Cajun flavor
- Low sodium
- MSG-free and Kosher
- Seasoning grilled meats
- Flavoring seafood dishes
- Enhancing vegetables and potatoes
2. Frontier Co-op Pizza Seasoning: Natural blend for pizza, pasta, & Italian dishes.
Exceptional flavor, large quantity, excellent value—a must-try spice!
- Highly rated
- Flavor
- Quality
- Value for money
- Aroma
- Longevity
- Freshness
Elevate your homemade pizzas and Italian dishes with Frontier Co-op's 1lb bulk bag of Pizza Seasoning. This kosher, non-irradiated blend, from the member-owned cooperative established in 1976, packs a flavorful punch. Featuring a vibrant mix of oregano, basil, garlic, onion, and a secret blend of spices including fennel seed, chili peppers, and thyme, this versatile seasoning transforms any pizza, from simple cheese to gourmet creations. Frontier Co-op's commitment to natural living ensures a delicious and ethically sourced product, perfect for adding that authentic Italian zest to your pasta dishes too. Enjoy the convenience of the large 16-ounce bag, providing ample seasoning for countless culinary adventures.
Frontier Co-op's Pizza Seasoning is a high-quality blend of herbs and spices, delivering exceptional flavor and value. Customers rave about its fresh aroma and taste, noting its versatility in various dishes, from pizza and Italian beef to tomato sauces, soups, and even baked salmon. The generous one-pound mylar bag provides excellent value, offering a significant quantity for frequent use. While some users mention the seasoning's coarse texture, easily remedied with a quick grind, and a strong fennel flavor (a delight for fennel lovers!), the overall consensus points to a superior product free from heavy metals, as verified by independent studies. Many appreciate the convenience of purchasing this flavorful blend in bulk, allowing for sharing with friends or refilling smaller containers. Despite a few comments regarding pricing and texture, the overwhelmingly positive feedback highlights Frontier Co-op Pizza Seasoning as a must-have for any spice enthusiast.
- Brand: Frontier Co-op
- Item Form: Powder
- Specialty: natural
- Unit Count: 16 Ounce
- Rate: 4.8 / 294
- Versatile seasoning for pizza, pasta, and Italian dishes
- Variety of herbs and spices including oregano, garlic, basil, and more
- Kosher and non-irradiated
- Homemade pizza topping
- Pasta sauce enhancement
- Italian-inspired dishes
3. Frontier Pizza Seasoning: Bell Pepper, Fennel, Oregano – Pasta & Salad
Delicious, versatile pizza seasoning; a flavor sensation!
- Highly rated
- Taste
- Quality
- Smell
- Spice blend
- Value for money
- Flavor
Elevate your culinary creations with Frontier Co-op Pizza Seasoning, a vibrant blend of bell pepper, fennel seed, and oregano packed into a convenient 1.04-ounce jar. This versatile seasoning isn't just for pizza; its zesty flavor profile perfectly complements pasta dishes and salads, adding a burst of Italian-inspired goodness. The carefully selected herbs and spices create a complex yet balanced taste, transforming ordinary meals into extraordinary ones. Whether you're crafting a homemade pizza masterpiece or adding depth to a simple salad, Frontier Co-op Pizza Seasoning delivers a delicious and aromatic experience. Enjoy the convenience and quality of this exceptional spice blend.
Frontier's Pizza Seasoning delivers a fantastic flavor experience, consistently praised for its delicious aroma and taste. Users rave about its versatility, enhancing not only pizzas (air fryer tortillas included!) but also Italian dishes, garlic bread, and even tomato soup. The unique blend, featuring a noticeable fennel note, is a standout among pre-made options, often described as "well-rounded" and flavorful. While some users noted a slight difference in taste compared to previous batches or other brands like McCormick's, the overwhelming consensus points to its superior quality and value, especially when purchased in bulk. The convenient shaker jar (a reusable glass container with the smaller size) is a nice touch. Though availability can be an issue at times, this non-GMO seasoning is a worthwhile addition to any spice rack, offering a convenient and delicious way to elevate a wide range of dishes.
- Brand: Frontier Co-op
- Rate: 4.6 / 1546
- Bell pepper, fennel seed & oregano blend
- Versatile use on pizza, pasta & salads
- Convenient 1.04-ounce jar
- Homemade pizza
- Pasta dishes
- Salads
4. Vlasic Keto-Friendly Hot Jalapeno Pepper Slices (5 x 12 oz)
Crispy, spicy, and delicious—the best jalapeños ever!
- Highly rated
- Flavor
- Quality
- Heat level
- Value for money
- Crunch
- Size
- Some controversy about
- Jar breaking
- Seal
Spice up your keto-friendly meals with Vlasic Deli Style Hot Jalapeno Pepper Slices. These fiery, flavorful slices, packed in twelve 12 fl oz jars (a 5-pack!), are a perfect addition to any dish. From the family-owned Vlasic brand, renowned for quality and innovation since 1912, these peppers deliver a delicious kick. Enjoy the satisfying crunch and bold jalapeno taste, knowing you're indulging in a low-carb, high-flavor snack or condiment. A convenient and delicious way to enjoy the legacy of Vlasic pickles, these peppers are a must-have for keto enthusiasts and spice lovers alike.
Vlasic Deli Style Hot Jalapeno Pepper Slices are a delicious and crunchy treat, far surpassing other brands like Mezzetta in terms of flavor and texture. These perfectly spicy (without being overly hot) jalapeno slices, packed in glass jars within a protective cardboard case, arrived in excellent condition. The satisfying crunch and tangy flavor make them ideal for adding a zesty kick to numerous dishes. While some users noted a shorter-than-ideal use-by date (a potential seller issue, not a manufacturer defect) and wished for larger jar sizes, the overall consensus is overwhelmingly positive. The superior quality and vibrant flavor of these Vlasic jalapenos are well worth the price, making them a must-have for any jalapeno lover. These convenient individual jars also solve the issue of finding this high-quality product in some stores.
- Rate: 4.6 / 1396
- Deli Style Hot Jalapeno Pepper Slices
- Keto Friendly
- Bulk Pack (5 x 12 oz jars)
- Ketogenic diets
- Spicy food lovers' meals
- Gourmet burger toppings