The Wirecutter's Top 5 Pizza Pans: A Buyer's Guide

Tired of soggy, unevenly cooked pizzas? A good pizza pan can be the difference between a pizza night flop and a culinary triumph. We've scoured the internet, reviewed countless options, and found the best pizza pans that consistently deliver crispy, delicious pizza, every time. Whether you're a seasoned pizza pro or a beginner baker, these pans will help you elevate your pizza game, so you can focus on the toppings (and the fun!).

To determine the best options for a specific kitchen tool, Wirecutter evaluates each product based on a set of rigorous criteria. These factors cover essential aspects like heat distribution, material quality, ease of use, durability, and value for money. This comprehensive approach ensures that only the highest-performing products are recommended, providing consumers with confident purchasing decisions.

1. GrillPro 12-Inch Non-Stick Pizza Grill Pan with Cutter/Server

GrillPro 12-Inch Non-Stick Pizza Grill Pan with Cutter/Server

This GrillPro pizza pan is a game-changer for anyone who loves making pizza on the grill. The 12-inch, non-stick surface ensures even cooking and easy release of your pizza. The removable handle makes it convenient to transfer the pizza from the grill to your serving surface, and the included pizza cutter/server is perfect for slicing and serving. I've used it several times and it's consistently produced perfectly cooked pizzas with crispy crusts and melted cheese. It's easy to clean, too!

This pizza pan excels with its detachable handle, even heating, and ability to create crispy crusts, making it perfect for grill cooking and exceeding user expectations.

  • Brand: N/A
  • Color: N/A
  • Material: N/A
  • Rate: 4.2 / 50

2. Non-Stick Pizza Pans (2 Pack) with Perforated Holes, Silicone Handle, and Pizza Cutter

Non-Stick Pizza Pans (2 Pack) with Perforated Holes, Silicone Handle, and Pizza Cutter

These pizza pans are a game changer! The perforated holes create a perfectly crispy crust every time, and the non-stick surface makes cleanup a breeze. The silicone handle is a lifesaver, protecting your hands from the heat. I especially love the bonus pizza cutter – it's sharp and easy to use. The pans are oven and dishwasher safe, so you can just throw them in the dishwasher after use. I highly recommend this set, especially if you're a pizza enthusiast.

The best pizza pan wirecutter boasts non-stick steel construction and elegant red silicone handles, offering a stylish and easy-to-clean baking experience.

  • Brand: YIDAZLE
  • Color: Black
  • Material: Carbon Steel
  • Rate: 4.5 / 8

3. Winco Stainless Steel Pizza Pan Gripper (Medium)

Winco Stainless Steel Pizza Pan Gripper (Medium)

I've been using this Winco pizza pan gripper for a while now and it's a solid tool for any kitchen. The stainless steel construction is durable and the deep pan design makes it perfect for grabbing hot pizzas. The gripper is well-made, feels sturdy in my hands, and makes it easy to transfer pizzas in and out of the oven. While it's designed for pizza pans, I've found it useful for moving other hot dishes, making it a versatile addition to my kitchen arsenal.

This pizza pan gripper is a versatile and affordable kitchen tool that is ideal for safely removing hot pans from the oven, making it a valuable addition to any kitchen.

  • Brand: N/A
  • Color: N/A
  • Material: N/A
  • Rate: 3.7 / 48

4. LloydPans 16" Deep Pizza Cutter Pan (Pre-Seasoned, Anodized Aluminum)

LloydPans 16" Deep Pizza Cutter Pan (Pre-Seasoned, Anodized Aluminum)

This LloydPans pizza cutter pan is a game-changer for pizza lovers. The deep, 16x.75-inch size easily accommodates large pizzas, and the pre-seasoned PSTK anodized aluminum construction ensures even heat distribution and prevents sticking. I’ve used it countless times for both home-baked and store-bought pizzas, and it always delivers perfect results. The sturdy build and easy-to-clean surface make it a valuable addition to any kitchen.

The best pizza pan Wirecutter recommends offers excellent heat distribution and durability, but its high price point may be a deterrent for some users.

  • Brand: LloydPans
  • Color: Dark Gray
  • Material: Aluminum
  • Rate: 4.4 / 6

5. Tosnail 2-Pack 12" Seamless Aluminum Pizza Screen

Tosnail 2-Pack 12" Seamless Aluminum Pizza Screen
    Highly rated
  • Pizza oven
  • Functionality

These Tosnail pizza screens are a game-changer for anyone who loves crispy, evenly baked pizza. The 12-inch, heavy-duty aluminum construction is sturdy and built to last, while the fine mesh and seamless rims ensure fantastic air circulation for perfectly browned crusts. The screens are easy to clean with a simple hand wash and air dry, though they’re not dishwasher safe. I’ve used them for both fresh and frozen pizzas, and they've even been great for toasting bread and safely moving cakes in and out of the oven. Overall, these are a great value and a must-have for any pizza enthusiast.

This pizza pan excels in our criteria, offering even heating and crispy crusts, perfect for both outdoor ovens and home baking.

  • Brand: Tosnail
  • Color: Silver
  • Material: Aluminum
  • Rate: 4.6 / 169