Pizza Nostra's reputation precedes it, and their second location promised to deliver the same exceptional pizza experience as its predecessor. This review focuses on their Vodka Pizza, a bold contender vying for the top spot alongside their already legendary "Double Triple Boom Regular Pepperoni Pizza." The anticipation was palpable; would this new location maintain the high standards set by its sister restaurant?This review delves into a detailed sensory journey, from the initial visual inspection of the pizza's golden-brown crust and generous toppings to the ultimate taste test. We explore the balance of flavors, the texture of the crust, and the overall dining experience. Discover whether the Vodka Pizza lives up to its potential, earns the coveted "Triple Boom Boom" rating, and ultimately, whether it's a worthy addition to Pizza Nostra's impressive menu.
Pros And Cons
- Great flavor
- Barely any flop (undercarriage)
- Spicy sauce with great tang
- Thin crust
- Crispy
- Cheesy
- More than sufficient pepperoni
- Spectacular
- Good even when cold
Read more: 5 Best Pizza Stones for Enhancing Your Green Egg Magic
Discovering Pizza Nostra's Sister Location
My pizza journey led me to Pizza Nostra's second location, a sister restaurant to one I'd previously reviewed. The anticipation was high, especially after my last positive experience. This location promised the same deliciousness, but would it deliver? The menu promised a delicious pepperoni vodka pizza, a potential rival to their already famed 'double triple boom regular pepperoni pizza.' I was eager to see if this new location held the same high standard.
First Impressions: A Visual Feast
Upon receiving the pizza, the visual appeal was undeniable. The golden-brown crust, the generous layer of pepperoni, and the vibrant red sauce all hinted at a delicious experience. I quickly noticed the minimal 'flop' in the crust, a positive indicator of a well-made pizza. The undercarriage looked perfectly cooked—a crispy foundation to support the delicious toppings.


Taste Test: A Spicy Delight
The first bite was a revelation. The flavors were intense, a perfect blend of spicy pepperoni, tangy vodka sauce, and a crispy, slightly charred crust. The heat was noticeable, but it was balanced by the acidity of the sauce. The taste was exceptional; a complex and satisfying experience that kept me coming back for more.

The Verdict: A Worthy Contender
Pizza Nostra's vodka pepperoni pizza is, without a doubt, a worthy competitor to their other pizzas. The quality of ingredients, the perfect balance of flavors, and the crisp, flavorful crust all contributed to an outstanding dining experience. I even enjoyed it cold the next day! It easily earns the 'triple boom boom' rating, and I wouldn't hesitate to visit again.