This review dives into the Lodge cast iron pizza pan, exploring its performance and ease of use in creating delicious, crispy pizzas. We put this thin yet sturdy pan to the test, comparing pizzas baked on a preheated pan versus one at room temperature to determine the impact on cooking time, crust texture, and overall flavor. Our experiment utilized pre-made dough, allowing for a focused assessment of the pan's capabilities and highlighting the importance of proper preheating techniques for optimal results. The results clearly demonstrate the pan's ability to achieve a superior crust, thanks to its efficient heat distribution and retention.This detailed review covers the unboxing experience, the pan's initial impression, and the step-by-step cooking process. We analyze the visual and textural differences between pizzas baked using varying preheating methods, ultimately evaluating the Lodge cast iron pizza pan's effectiveness in achieving a crispy, evenly cooked crust. Discover whether this pan lives up to its promises and learn valuable tips and tricks to elevate your homemade pizza game. Find out if the Lodge cast iron pizza pan delivers a deep dish delight, worthy of a spot in your kitchen arsenal.
Pros And Cons
- Don't have a rim, allowing for more than just pizza
- Work great
- Nice
- Fairly thin
Read more: Lloydpans vs Detroit Style Pizza Co Detroit - Which Pans Are Better?
Unboxing and First Impressions
The Lodge cast iron pizza pan arrived well-packaged, maintaining its pristine condition. The pan itself is impressively thin yet sturdy, a welcome departure from some bulkier options. The subtle rings on the back suggest thoughtful design aimed at optimal heat distribution and retention. Initial inspection revealed a smooth, pre-seasoned surface, ready for immediate use.
Pizza Making Process
Using pre-made pizza dough from Papa Murphy's, I prepared two pizzas. One pan was preheated on the stovetop, while the other remained at room temperature for comparison. Both pizzas were topped with marinara sauce and a generous amount of cheese, a mix of finely and coarsely shredded varieties. A small amount of marinara was added to one pizza to mark it as the preheated pan pizza.
Cooking and Results
Both pizzas were baked at 425 degrees Fahrenheit for approximately 12 minutes, with a mid-bake rotation. The preheated pan yielded a crispier crust, displaying a noticeably darker color along the edges compared to the pan that started at room temperature. The color difference suggested improved heat distribution and faster cooking time. Taste test confirmed the preheated pan creating a better crust.
Final Verdict
The Lodge cast iron pizza pan delivers on its promise of even cooking and a crispy crust. The preheating technique significantly enhances the crust’s texture and color. While the pan's thinness is initially surprising, it proves advantageous for heat transfer and even browning. For the best results, preheat the pan, use oil or non-stick spray to prevent sticking, and cook for at least 15 minutes, depending on pizza thickness. Highly recommended for pizza lovers seeking a superior crust.